Skip to content

The best dialer for an insurance agent changes with the call.

The best dialer for an insurance agent is one that changes mode with the call, because the rules follow who answers: one call at a time for a person at home, up to 5 lines for a business. Five at a Time does both in a $150 seat. For Medicare Advantage and Part D, CMS bars cold calling whatever dialer you use[1].

Which mode for which call

The number is how many lines we would run. It is our reading of the rules beside it, not a rule itself, and none of it is legal advice.

  1. 0do not dial

    Medicare Advantage or Part D, to someone who has not asked

    A beneficiary at home

    CMS bars plans and their agents and brokers from “telephone solicitation (that is, cold calling)” of beneficiaries[1][2]. No dialer setting changes that.

    42 CFR 422.2264(a)(2)(iv) and 423.2264(a)(2)(iv)

  2. 1solo

    Medicare, to someone who asked for the call

    A beneficiary who returned your call, sent in a reply card or gave consent

    The rule says these calls “are not considered unsolicited”[1]. They are still calls to a person at home, so one at a time.

    42 CFR 422.2264(a)(3)

  3. 1solo

    Your own clients, about plan business

    A current enrollee, or a client who holds another policy you sell

    The rule lists agents and brokers “calling clients who are enrolled in other products they may sell, such as automotive or home insurance” as plan business[1]. It also bars unsolicited calls about other lines of business made to generate Medicare leads.

    42 CFR 422.2264(b)(1)

  4. 1solo

    Final expense, life and health leads

    A person at home

    The consumer calling rules are written for this call: calling hours, the Do Not Call Registry and a limit on abandoned calls[4][5]. On one line only one phone is ringing, so two people cannot answer at once.

    47 CFR 64.1200 and 16 CFR 310.4

  5. 5five at a time

    Group benefits, commercial lines, recruiting other agencies

    A business, on its business line

    The FTC’s rule exempts most calls between a telemarketer and a business[6], and its guidance says the registry provisions do not apply to business-to-business calls[7]. A direct dial that turns out to be somebody’s own mobile is a harder question.

    16 CFR 310.6(b)(7)

Why a person at home gets one call at a time

A summary with sources, not legal advice.

On five lines the dialer rings five numbers and connects you to the first person who answers. If a second person answers the same round, you are already talking. On Five at a Time that person hears a short automated apology and the call ends.

The FTC’s Telemarketing Sales Rule calls a call abandoned when a person answers and is not connected to a sales representative within two seconds of their completed greeting. Its safe harbor allows that on no more than 3% of calls answered by a person, per campaign over 30 days, with other conditions[5]. The FCC has a parallel rule written for “all telemarketing calls” answered live[4]. On October 28, 2025 it proposed deleting that rule, and a proposal is not a repeal[9].

Vendors disagree about whether the second person in a round counts as an abandoned call. On a list of businesses, that is a question for your lawyer. On a list of people at home, where those rules are written for the call, we would not run the experiment. Solo mode dials one number at a time, you are waiting on the line when it is answered, and nobody is hung up on.

The more often a list answers, the more often two people answer the same round. How many lines to dial works through the arithmetic, and Is parallel dialing legal? has every rule with its source.

Medicare: cold calls are barred, whatever the dialer

From 42 CFR 422.2264, the Medicare Advantage rule on beneficiary contact. The Part D rule, 423.2264, has the same paragraph for Part D sponsors. It covers a plan and “its agents and brokers”.

Barred when unsolicited

“Use telephone solicitation (that is, cold calling), robocalls, text messages, or voicemail messages”

The rule’s own examples: calls based on referrals, calls to former enrollees who have disenrolled (except disenrollment surveys), calls to people who attended a sales event unless they gave express permission, and calls to confirm that mailed information arrived[1].

Not counted as unsolicited

“Calls are not considered unsolicited if the beneficiary provides consent or initiates contact with the plan.”

The rule’s examples are returning a phone call and calling someone who completed a business reply card requesting contact[1].

Plan business

“Agents/brokers calling clients who are enrolled in other products they may sell, such as automotive or home insurance.”

Also on the list: calling current enrollees to discuss Medicare products. Not allowed: “unsolicited calls about other lines of business as a means of generating leads for Medicare plans”. The plan must tell the people it contacts, in writing and at least once a year, that they can opt out of these calls[1].

During the Open Enrollment Period. A separate paragraph says a Medicare Advantage organization may not “knowingly target or send unsolicited marketing materials to any MA enrollee during the Open Enrollment Period”, and may not “call or otherwise contact former enrollees who have selected a new plan during the AEP”. A one-on-one meeting with a sales agent at the beneficiary’s request is allowed[3].

Final expense is life insurance, and neither rule names it. The marketing rule does bar a plan from marketing “non-health care related products to prospective enrollees during any MA sales activity or presentation”, which it calls cross-selling[3]. Whether a final expense pitch falls under that is a question for your carrier’s compliance team. For the call itself, the consumer calling rules above are the ones written for it. This page does not cover Medicare Supplement policies.

For a dialer, this means there is no Medicare cold list to load. The calls left are people who asked and people who are already your clients, and both go on solo mode.

What the dialer does, and what stays your job

Five at a Time has safeguards. You are the caller, and compliance is yours.

The dialer

Switches mode with the list
Four modes, picked before each session: solo, double, triple, five at a time. The same seat dials a final expense list solo in the morning and a list of employers on five lines after lunch.
Skips leads outside calling hours
Leads are skipped before 8am and after 6pm in the lead’s local time, read from the area code. The FCC’s rule for residential and wireless numbers runs to 9 p.m.[4] and Florida’s ends at 8 p.m.[8], so 6pm sits inside both. The hour comes from the area code, which is wrong for a mobile that moved states.
Keeps one Do Not Call list for the agency
A Do Not Call list that blocks a number for the whole team. Mark someone who asks you to stop and no agent on the team can dial them.
Records and summarises
Calls are recorded and transcribed, with an AI summary on the lead. Recording is on by default. If you do not have the consent the law requires where you and the other person are, ask us to switch it off before you call (Terms, section 10.1).
Calls from local numbers
Each business gets its own five local numbers, picked from the area codes its lead list has most of. Each call goes out from the number nearest the lead’s area code.

You

Scrubbing against the Do Not Call Registry
The dialer does not check your list against the National Do Not Call Registry. Our Terms have you scrub it before you call, unless a valid exemption applies (Terms, section 7.2).
Consent, and the record of it
Any consent the law requires for the people you call is yours to hold, and for Medicare that includes the request or consent that makes a call solicited. We can ask to see those records (Acceptable Use Policy).
Where the leads came from
Every list has to come from a source you can name and show. Lists scraped from websites or bought from a seller who cannot say where a number came from are not allowed.
Recording consent
Some states require everyone on the call to agree to a recording. California requires the consent of all parties to a confidential communication[10].
Your state and your carriers
Your state insurance department and the carriers you are appointed with have rules of their own. This page does not cover them.

Read these before you buy

  • People call you back. The numbers are for outbound calls. Calls back to them may not ring through.
  • You run an agency management system or a CRM. No Salesforce, HubSpot, Outreach or Salesloft sync. Leads come in by CSV.
  • You dial from your phone between appointments. No mobile app. It runs in a desktop browser.

If you came looking for a predictive dialer

A predictive dialer is built for call centres. It places more calls than there are free agents and connects whoever answers, so some people answer with nobody there. The 3% limit above is the cap on that[5].

Five at a Time is not a predictive dialer. Solo mode is a power dialer: one call at a time, with you on the line. The other modes are parallel dialing for one agent, which rings several numbers and connects you to the first pickup. The three kinds compared.

Which of ours, for which agency

Five at a Time

The best dialer for people who dial all day. Pick it when agents are on the phone most of the day and the agency calls both people and businesses: solo and five lines are in the same seat, with the numbers and 2,500 minutes included.

$150 a seat a month

DialSheet

The best dialer for a solopreneur. Pick it when you are one agent, or the bill decides. Its free plan is a power dialer with 500 calls a month on your own Twilio account, and a line we run for you is $49 a month[11].

Free, or $49 a month managed

Questions from insurance agents

What is the best dialer for insurance agents selling Medicare and final expense?

We make two dialers, so weigh this as the maker’s opinion. The best dialer for that mix is one that dials one call at a time, because both are calls to people at home, and that keeps track of who asked not to be called. Five at a Time does that in solo mode for $150 a seat a month, and DialSheet does it free for one agent, with 500 calls a month on your own Twilio account. For Medicare Advantage and Part D, CMS rules bar cold calling beneficiaries whatever dialer you use, so the dialer is only for people who asked for the call or are already your clients.

Can I cold call Medicare beneficiaries?

Not for Medicare Advantage or Part D plans. 42 CFR 422.2264 and 423.2264 say plans and their agents and brokers may not, if unsolicited, “use telephone solicitation (that is, cold calling), robocalls, text messages, or voicemail messages”. The rule’s examples include calls based on referrals. A call is not unsolicited if the beneficiary gave consent or made contact first, such as returning a call or sending back a business reply card. This is a summary, not legal advice.

Can a Medicare rep contact past clients during OEP?

42 CFR 422.2263(b)(7) says that during the Open Enrollment Period a Medicare Advantage organization may not “call or otherwise contact former enrollees who have selected a new plan during the AEP”, and may not target the OEP as a chance to make further sales. It does allow a one-on-one meeting with a sales agent at the beneficiary’s request. Separately, 422.2264 bars unsolicited calls to former enrollees who have disenrolled, except for disenrollment surveys. Ask your carrier’s compliance team about your own case.

Is a predictive dialer or a power dialer better for insurance?

For calls to people at home, we would use a power dialer: one call at a time, with the agent on the line when the person answers. A predictive dialer places more calls than there are free agents, so some people answer with nobody there, and the abandoned-call rules cap that at 3% of calls answered by a person. Five at a Time is not a predictive dialer. Its solo mode is a power dialer.

Can I use a parallel dialer for final expense leads?

No rule we read bans dialing several numbers at once with a live agent. The risk is what happens when two people answer the same round: one gets the agent, and on Five at a Time the other hears a short automated apology and the call ends. Vendors disagree about whether that counts as an abandoned call. On lists of people at home we would run solo mode and keep five lines for business lists. This is not legal advice.

Does Five at a Time scrub my list against the Do Not Call Registry?

No. It keeps a Do Not Call list for your team and blocks those numbers for every agent. Checking a list against the National Do Not Call Registry is the caller’s job under our Terms, before the list is called, unless a valid exemption applies.

What hours can insurance agents call?

The FCC’s rule for residential and wireless numbers sets 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. in the called person’s local time, and Florida ends the day at 8 p.m. Five at a Time skips leads before 8am and after 6pm in the lead’s local time, read from the area code. That is a safeguard and not a guarantee, because a mobile number can move states.

How much does a dialer cost for an insurance agent?

Five at a Time is $150 a seat a month with 2,500 minutes, which covers about 128 dials a working day, then 5 cents a minute. DialSheet, which we also make, is free for one agent with 500 calls a month on your own Twilio account, and $49 a month for a line we run for you with 1,500 minutes.

Sources

  1. CMS, 42 CFR 422.2264, "Beneficiary contact" (Cornell Legal Information Institute). Medicare Advantage: unsolicited contact (a), contact for plan business (b). Read November 21, 2026.
  2. CMS, 42 CFR 423.2264, "Beneficiary contact" (Cornell Legal Information Institute). The same paragraph for Part D sponsors. Read November 21, 2026.
  3. CMS, 42 CFR 422.2263, "General marketing requirements" (Cornell Legal Information Institute). Cross-selling (b)(4), the Open Enrollment Period (b)(7). Read November 21, 2026.
  4. FCC rules under the TCPA, 47 CFR 64.1200 (Cornell Legal Information Institute). Abandoned calls (a)(6) and (a)(7), calling hours (c)(1), the registry (c)(2), wireless numbers (e). Read November 13, 2026.
  5. FTC Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 CFR 310.4 (Cornell Legal Information Institute). Abandoned calls (b)(1)(iv), the safe harbor (b)(4), calling hours (c). Read November 13, 2026.
  6. FTC Telemarketing Sales Rule, 16 CFR 310.6 (Cornell Legal Information Institute). The business-to-business exemption, (b)(7). Read November 13, 2026.
  7. Federal Trade Commission, "Complying with the Telemarketing Sales Rule". Says the registry provisions do not apply to business-to-business calls. Read November 13, 2026.
  8. Florida Statutes (2024), s. 501.616. Hours and the three-call limit, (6). Read November 13, 2026.
  9. Kelley Drye, "Look who’s calling: FCC includes proposals to roll back several TCPA rules as part of call branding initiative". A law firm’s summary of the FCC’s October 28, 2025 proposal. Read November 13, 2026.
  10. California Penal Code, s. 632 (FindLaw). Consent of all parties to record a confidential communication. Read November 13, 2026.
  11. DialSheet, pricing page. Read November 14, 2026.

Rules change, and this page is a summary and not legal advice. If something here is out of date, tell us and we will fix it.

one at a time is for people with time.

10 conversations or one day on three lines, free. No card and no business check. Nothing is charged when the trial ends. To keep dialing you verify your business, save a card and start the plan at $150 a seat a month.

Start free trial

See pricing or read the refund policy first.